WW3 Threat Expert: The Warning We Are Ignoring, The Only Way Out Is THIS! | Dr Sarah Paine

1h 41m 9.9M views 29 Oct 2026

Is it worth your time?

You get an analysis of how historical imperial strategies, military miscalculations, and economic sanctions shape current global security threats.

This conversation examines the historical roots of modern geopolitical conflicts and the accelerating breakdown of international alliances. It investigates how abandoning established maritime norms and launching disastrous military campaigns risk catastrophic global instability.

Maritime and continentalist empires. Paine warns that global conflicts are accelerating because reckless leaders are abandoning a rules-based maritime order in favor of continentalist territorial conquest. She explains that while industrial commerce compounds wealth safely, land-grabbing empires burn resources and barrel humanity toward a second Cold War that could end in nuclear destruction.

The Iran war. Paine argues that the Iran war ranks among the most incompetent conflicts in history because it devastated the United States economy and shattered vital alliances. She points out that the adversary immediately choked off the Strait of Hormuz, transforming the United States into a primary global target while fueling worldwide energy shocks.

The Russia-Ukraine war. Paine expects that Vladimir Putin's invasion of Ukraine will remain a pivotal error that burns through Russia's Cold War arsenal while hardening Ukrainian resistance. She notes that heavy state spending consumes roughly 40 percent of the national budget, and persistent inflation forced the Central Bank of Russia to hike interest rates above 20 percent.

How Did the World Get So Close to World War III?

I see war and conflict everywhere: Putin invading, Trump in Iran, and rioting and disorder on the streets of Paris. Historically, countries organized as empires where land was the currency of power. This continentalist world is about taking territory, which burns wealth.

This shifted toward a maritime world order, led by powers like Britain. The Industrial Revolution was a game-changer because it changed the currency of power from land to industry, commerce, and trade, allowing for compounded wealth to buy armies. The maritime order compounds wealth through a rules-based order where your piece of plastic works everywhere. If this goes away, the billionaires funneling money into the continentalists will become casualties as their world disappears.

We are potentially barreling into a world war with reckless people running large, important countries. Once wars start, they are easy to begin but hard to end because whoever is losing doubles down long after they have lost.

A positive objective is making something happen, like snatching Maduro and putting him in a New York prison. A negative objective is preventing something from happening, such as a parent preventing a child from getting run over. Negative objectives are incredibly important; I believe governments are primarily about preventing disasters. This includes preventing foreign invasions, inspecting bridges to stop them from collapsing, licensing professionals to prevent malpractice, and providing education to prevent illiteracy.

Was the Iran War a Catastrophic Mistake?

The Iran war is probably one of the most incompetent wars in human history. In a war, if you must have one, you put all the costs on your opponent and minimize your own. Instead, this war has trashed the US economy and blown the US alliance system. While Iran is undoubtedly hurting, the collateral damage of taking down the world's economy transforms the United States from an annoyance into the primary adversary for just about everyone.

Before a war, an assessment must look at not just your strengths and the enemy's weaknesses, but also the enemy's strengths and your own weaknesses. Someone should have warned that the first thing Iran would do is shut down Hormuz. It is like a hot water bottle; if you cork it, anyone without an alternate coastline cannot get things out by sea. Narrow seas are easy to shut down in wartime, just as Ukraine shut down the Black Sea using shore artillery and mines. We would have to go to Diego Garcia, a little base in the middle of nowhere 2,500 miles away.

Where the Trump Administration Went Wrong

I asked about the misunderstanding because you'd think smart people at the White House would have figured it out. In the first Trump administration, there was General Mattis; now we have Major Pete, who is really good at identifying and firing Black people and women. They are now testing testosterone. I don't know if you remember when you were an adolescent and testosterone was peaking, but I doubt there is a correlation between that and your greatest reasoning powers.

These people are historically unqualified for their jobs, which makes them profoundly dangerous. They've undermined the futures of their own children and the prospects for the Republican Party. I distinguish between type A and type B American hubris. Type A is the belief that all decisions in the world that matter happen in the United States. Type B, which applies to some tech bros, is the failure to realize that being really good at something doesn't make you good at everything. You need the humility to understand the limits of your expertise and when to listen to others.

It is important to talk across political divides, but what is happening now is just straight-up yes-men. They've committed pivotal errors and permanently damaged US national security. It's the first time in my life I've heard a US president talk about taking other people's countries. Trump talked about taking Venezuela and making Canada the 51st state. He thought Iran would be a walk in the park, believing he could behead the leader and the people would rise up.

There is also what I call half-court tennis: if you are on team America, you just cross the net without looking at other things. Real football enthusiasts know about all the teams, not just the home team. If you've seen Iran's Lego videos, they demonstrate that the Iranians have a deep understanding of Americans.

Some things, as desirable as they are, are simply unattainable. If you pursue an unfeasible objective, you overextend yourself. A problem is something you can solve, but the Greatest Generation understood that the lethal threat of the Soviet Union could not be solved; trying to do so would lead to a nuclear end for all of us.

Instead, they used sanctions to depress Soviet growth while maximizing growth within their own alliance system. By minimizing the growth of those who cannot behave, the relative threat diminishes over time. You hope for an intergenerational change where the other side reassesses, but if they don't, you remain safe behind castle walls, handling the situation at an affordable cost because sanctions cost them more than you.

But are we trying to solve Iran? There are 90 million of them. Nazi Germany had a population of about 80 million, and the occupation force after World War II was about 1.5 million just to occupy Germany. To contain the nuclear threat in Iran at an affordable cost, the Obama deal was created. All permanent members of the UN Security Council and the EU signed on to an intrusive inspection system to get Iran to dial back its nuclear capabilities. It was feasible and mitigated the threat to make it bearable.

Now, if you don't have a nuke, you're toast. Through Putin's war and our approach to Iran, we have incentivized proliferation. It is profoundly self-defeating.

Putin's Biggest Mistake in the Russia-Ukraine War

These concepts are useful because you can apply them to other things. A pivotal error occurs when the choices you have after a decision are far worse than the ones you had before, and you never get the old ones back. Vladimir Putin's invasion of Ukraine was a pivotal error. Russia has burned through its Cold War arsenal; Putin would have fared better by sticking with the easy walk-in of his little green men into Crimea and Donbas and slowly destabilizing Ukraine over years. Instead, he has massively contributed to Ukrainian national identity, which often emerges from wars. Britain similarly contributed to the development of US national identity during the American Revolution, as separate colonies developed a cohesive sense of nation and national institutions. Ukraine is doing the same.

Regarding the Iran war, we've lost our alliance system. Someone else may reassess and try to restore things, but we will never be the trusted partner again. The post-World War II world is collapsing, and we are entering a second Cold War that could end in nuclear war.

Systems work through norms, like traffic. Regardless of which side of the road you drive on or the stop lights you follow, most people follow the rules of the road. The rules-based order and the US legal order were based on norms of following them—such as congratulating the other side after losing an election instead of claiming they cheated. Now, the United States is pulling out of this order.

This existential threat has led to the most rapid institution building in Europe. The Baltic eight, including Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania, are organizing security with Nordic countries—Finland, Sweden, Norway, Denmark, and Iceland. Remilitarization is occurring, and space ports are being developed. Britain, Norway, and Sweden have had space ports since the '60s, and Britain is building a new one in the Shetland Islands to launch its own satellite system. Europe is also moving toward local credit card payment systems. There is an app called boycott that tells European users if a product is American so they don't buy it. Prime Minister Carney of Canada is traveling to organize the middle powers because the United States has gone rogue. As America, we were on the right side of two world wars and made an incredibly positive contribution in many ways.

Should America Stop Fighting Other Countries' Wars?

Do not send combat troops all over the place as we were doing in the Middle East. Instead, position people like Ukraine to succeed by giving them what they need to solve this without sending any troops. That is a cheap thing to do.

The un-cheap thing is blowing our alliance systems so that we are being boycotted. Many U.S. industries are being hurt; for example, Kentucky bourbon makers have to shut down because Canadians won't buy our booze. If Canada is only 5 or 10% of your business, a boycott might be your entire profit margin. Canada is now arranging to sell its energy to Europe and other places to de-risk from us.

Why Americans Are Tired of Paying for Foreign Wars

It goes back to limited and unlimited objectives. Unlimited objectives include regime change and, in the most extreme variant, genocide. Hitler had both. Putin has a very unlimited variant because he wants to not only take over Ukraine, but shoot up a good part of the government, including small children; he was trying to execute the Zelensky family. Additionally, he wants to eliminate the purveyors of Ukrainian culture, which is called genocide. You can have the most unlimited combination of genocide plus regime change, or just regime change. Limited objectives are when you only want half of a country. When you realize you got it wrong, you say, "I got new information and here's why I think differently." But I believe Russia has unlimited objectives and that Putin wants to restore the old Soviet empire.

Russia has been the backwater of Europe forever under the czars. Smirnoff's is a British company; they don't even produce the vodka. It has a failing economic model. During the Cold War, it exported communism everywhere, setting back living standards and causing many deaths because children weren't getting vaccines. Based on this legacy of incompetence, Putin thinks he has the right to rule everyone else. He's a colonialist who wants to steal everyone else's stuff. At the beginning of the Ukraine war, people were stealing washing machines. Ukrainians don't want to live without washing machines.

There is a Russian type A hubris—a belief that they are superior to all others, though they can't figure out what they're superior on, so they come up with something abstract. Zelensky told me that when the Russian soldiers rolled in, they had brought food for 3 to 10 days and uniforms to celebrate the victory parade because they thought the war would be that easy. Instead, they were met with Ukrainian civilians throwing Molotov cocktails at their tanks.

The Deadly Military Strategy of Death Ground

They've underestimated the culture of the people. If you have an unlimited objective against someone, you put them on death ground; if they don't fight, you'll just kill them, so their only alternative is to fight. Expect one hell of a fight, which can transform the most dysfunctional country into a lethal adversary, as Hitler discovered with the Soviet Union. Stalin shot much of his officer corps and created a famine in Ukraine, the breadbasket, which is exactly what Putin has done to Ukraine now and what the United States is undoubtedly doing to Iran.

My understanding is the late Ayatollah was against having nukes, but no one says his successor is. If they are on death ground as long as Donald Trump and Bibi Netanyahu are in power, they will cause trouble until those two are gone. Those who want to keep Netanyahu and Trump in power should understand it will make Iran go on longer. I'm terrified Trump will drop a tactical nuke somewhere and then things are really over. The United States would be forever this despicable country—the only one in the world to have dropped nukes on anyone, twice on Japan, and then a third on Iran.

If you had told me 10 years ago that where we are now was remotely possible, I would say you're insane: that the United States was going to toss our alliances, tell Canada they are our 51st state, and tell Greenland we're taking them and they should behave themselves.

How Rising Gas Prices Could Affect Your Future

Costs are rising because of this war and the resulting energy shock. One third of Americans voted for where we are now, one third voted for anything but this, and one third couldn't get off their couch. A two-party state is absolutely necessary to see blind spots.

Trump is not going to reassess this war. She has been tweeting that because costs for petrol and other things are rising in the UK, we should just let Russia take Ukraine to stabilize energy. But a staple in war colleges is that the enemy gets a vote; the Russians are going to come whether you like it or not. Russian history shows they are continentalists who go forward, forward, forward.

Looking at the map of places Putin has taken, he has basically taken Belarus and parts of Ukraine. Putin came to power in the second Chechen War, then in 2008 he went after Georgia and helped two places separate. If you draw a circle, it is like the round spaceship in The Jetsons; it is 360 degrees around their borders, extending outward.

The Cold War ended on Western terms with Bush Sr., and Helmut Kohl did a truly masterful job at war termination. Then came the magical inter-Cold War period where China and Russia turned inward and the United States more or less followed the rules. If Putin keeps any part of Ukraine, it is a glowing mess.

Will Ukraine Seek Revenge Against Russia?

Zelenskyy told me this will go on forever. He found one trench Russian soldiers had left containing 500 tortured bodies. He implied it is naive to think the families of those people will allow a sudden stop or not want revenge. Zelenskyy told me, "After seeing that, I know I probably shouldn't say this, but I want revenge. If you see what I saw, you would want revenge, too."

For most of my life, Germans wore the crown of infamy for World War II, which took heinousness to a new level. Now, Vlad the Bad owns that crown for Russians. Germans reformed their educational system, so no German now has responsibility for what happened then, but many Russians have responsibility for what is happening now.

Russia ran the Soviet Union. Like how the word France includes all five republics, monarchies, and Napoleon, Russia's history spans from the Romanov dynasty—who aspired to Western connections, though Nicholas II said they were 200 years behind and would do it their way—to the communists who wanted to overthrow the entire capitalist world order. Putin hasn't changed.

The continentalists are profoundly dangerous. They want to divide the world into spheres of influence, like the old empires of Eurasia, fighting on the edges about who gets what. This includes Russia, China, and Donald Trump. Trump is claiming Canadian territory and Greenland, and he's kidnapped a head of state. Trump would say it was Biden's fault; his favorite line is that this war never would have happened if he was in power.

In domestic policy, consequences of a new law usually roll out over years, but not in the Iran war. Every time you load up at the pump, you have a weekly reminder that Donald Trump's war has done a number on you. It's not Biden. Trump would say we couldn't let Iran get nuclear weapons, but he's incentivized them to get them, making it much more likely now.

This is the problem with normalizing lies in the United States. The Soviet Union collapsed in large part because it was built on lies. Since it was run by a communist plan, if you were running your staff and decided how many cameras you needed, you would exaggerate what you needed and understate what you had because you weren't sure the plan would provide. The further up the food chain you go, the more ludicrous the data becomes. In central Moscow, they come up with a plan that grossly misallocates capital and labor, and they don't notice the disaster until it's metastasized.

An economy doubles at different growth rates according to the equation: the natural log of two over the growth rate. If your economy grows at 1% per annum, it doubles in about 69 or 70 years; at 3%, a 2% differential, it doubles in 23 years. If you do dumbassery like tariffs or enter a war that sends prices up and messes things up, you suffer. But if you're smarter and sanction the other guy, knocking off 2% growth, they wait 71 years to double instead of 23. Sanctions don't solve problems, but you shrink the opposing piggy bank while growing yourself by cooperating with allies. It's a form of chemotherapy; you don't eliminate the tumor, but you try to shrink it back.

What Happens Next in Putin's Russia?

It's already done. He's just going to escalate and keep going forward because he can't go back.

What's wonderful about elections is that they throw you out of office, but no one kills you or takes your bank accounts away. In Russia, under Stalin, he was busy shooting everybody until he died and Khrushchev became his successor. That successor generation decided you shouldn't be killed when you left office; instead, they send you to your dacha, your summer house.

Putin's problem is a problem with dictators: for many of them, there's no off-ramp where they're alive. If he dies naturally, that happens to all of us, but he's arranged it so there is no retirement plan except something really ugly.

What Would Happen if Putin Stepped Down?

Probably not, because people will come kill him; he's the whole protection racket running stuff. It seems like he's got such a tight grip, but dictatorships seem eternal until the day they shatter, which is impossible to predict.

Take the Romanov dynasty. Nicholas II, like Vlad the Bad, decided to enter a recreational war he didn't have to: the Russo-Japanese War of 1904-1905. Russia is the largest country on the planet with tons of resources, but they have no economic model to develop them because they refuse to follow rules that allow people to start businesses and keep their money.

Nicholas didn't build a railway system in western Russia, so by World War I, he couldn't deploy his troops well or allow allies to supply him, as Russia's main ports are the Baltic and Black Seas. If Nicholas hadn't done his dumbassery and had built railways, he might have avoided the food riots in St. Petersburg. Now, China is providing what's vital for him.

The Real Reason China Is Backing Russia

They want the United States out of everyone's business, but they don't particularly like Russia either. If Russia weakens itself here, China will benefit. China needs the resources.

My graduate dissertation was a history of the Russo-Chinese border. Russia took territory from the Chinese sphere of influence greater than all of the US east of the Mississippi. The Chinese remember that. Now, China is supplying Russia with the resources they need to make missiles and other things. They are making money from it, but they are also weakening Russia. Because Russia has been sanctioned on its energy and other things, China is getting these resources at much reduced prices and driving a hard bargain.

In the past, the Russians had nuclear weapons and other tools to dissuade the Chinese from playing Mr. Except Vladimir Putin has squandered all of that; he can't even deal with Ukraine, let alone this. They have made a massive pivotal error. They aren't having kids, so the long-term effects are getting worse. They still have nuclear weapons, but you have to maintain them, and the Russians are consummate liars. My understanding is that India and China have told Russia that using them would be a massive no-no.

What Would It Take to End the War in Ukraine?

From speaking to Zelenskyy, it sounds like he will not yield an inch of Ukraine to Putin, yet Putin must walk away looking like he achieved a victory for his people and his power. In World War II, the allies won, but at an obscene cost; 55 million people died, including tens of millions of Russians.

It is far better to deploy your diplomats and lawyers to international institutions. The deal may not be perfect, but wealth will compound if people your age can start businesses under laws that allow it instead of poaching others' stuff. Morals matter. Protect your national security and your prosperity.

For your friend, protecting British national security will involve Europe, because Britain cannot do well without a healthy Western Europe.

Why Europe's Economy Is Under Pressure

Internal conflicts are taking place. I left my hotel and the streets were on fire; at night, people in balaclavas run into shops and smash them to pieces. I think about the UK; I just read a Sunday Times headline stating Britain is going broke, with 3 trillion in debt and 110 billion in annual interest, leaving the new chancellor little room to maneuver.

Consider the generation at the end of World War II, which within ten years set up the institutional architecture that held the peace in Europe for the next three generations. Conversely, this is a tremendous opportunity, before the concrete sets again, for people to get moving and work on the next set of institutions to improve Europe's lackluster growth rates.

Americans think all their problems are about immigrants coming across the border.

How the US Tax System Shapes America's Future

I am all for legal immigration, but you can expel people humanely without being cruel.

In Europe, people identified that it is hard for the young to make it, creating a feeling of hopelessness and no opportunities. In the United States, I suspect the answer is not immigrants, but our tax code. A handful of people have become billionaires over the last 15 years, which you cannot do without the tax code.

Another piece in the United States is our monopolies, where you own an industry and set the prices. Then there is monopsony, where you hire such a large percentage of the workforce in a particular area that you dictate wages. Wages in the United States have been driven downwards; people work 40-hour weeks or more and cannot make ends meet while money is funneled into a handful of families' coffers. Apparently, there are a thousand families worth a billion or better because the world is different now with digital assets.

You would have to talk to a tax specialist, but the US tax code that allows people to become hugely wealthy is an area where there is a missing podcast—someone actually reading the tax code, breaking it down into pieces, and talking about the human connection of it all.

Ads

Occam's razor is a philosophical principle stating that the simplest solution is often the best. For example, if you want to lose a couple of pounds, using a calorie tracker, electronic weights, and an AI coach adds unnecessary complexity to the process.

Why the US Midterm Elections Could Change Everything

The midterms are coming up, where you're electing a percentage of the US Senate, all of the House of Representatives, and governors. House terms are two years and senators serve six staggered years. Right now, Trump has power because Republicans control the House, the Senate, and the Supreme Court, but polls suggest he will likely lose both the Senate and the House.

If he sends ICE agents to polling stations, people walk away with voting machines, or he offers people $5,000 to vote Republican, it will be a national IQ test for the United States. Today's Republican party isn't remotely what it was with Eisenhower or Ronald Reagan, who recommended protecting national security and promoting prosperity. It is the fault of the party that enabled him at every point.

For example, the Republican party confirmed Pete Hegseth; while his rank is okay, he is not fit to run the Pentagon. That was an act of supreme dereliction of duty. They could have demanded another General Mattis, and we might not be in Iran today.

If Republicans lose the midterms, they will have to cooperate with Democrats to pass bipartisan legislation, despite making it clear they won't. However, Trump still has executive powers to sign orders and change facts on the ground; if it later turns out to be illegal, he's already done the thing. He cut down all the legacy trees at a golf course he cares about in Washington. Imagine someone going into Richmond Park in London and leveling all the 800-year-old trees.

What's Happening to the Democratic Core?

We often think of China or Russia, but the democratic core consists of the democracies: the West, Central Europe, Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, New Zealand, Australia, Canada, and the United States. However, threatening to invade Greenland or make Canada our 51st state does not make you the democratic core.

Taiwan is 1/250 the size of China, but it proves that a vibrant democracy is possible for the Han, the preponderant ethnic group of China. The racist idea that democracy and the Han are mutually exclusive is nonsense. If there were fair elections, neither Xi Jinping nor Vladimir Putin would be in power, which is why they regard democracies as an existential threat. We tolerate each other, provide legal protections, and allow people to keep the fruits of their businesses.

China became wealthy when it joined the maritime rules-based order and followed the rules. It can compete and compound wealth, but not if it launches wars. After the Qing Dynasty fell in 1911-1912, the Warlord Period saw provincial leaders duking it out, eventually coalescing into a bilateral communist nationalist fight circa 1927.

In 1930, the first "America Firsters" responded to the Great Depression by putting up huge tariffs. Despite economists warning President Hoover that others would respond in kind, he did it anyway, tanking global economies and deepening the Depression. Deciding the only solution was an empire large enough to be self-sufficient, Japan moved into Manchuria in 1931. Japan later attacked Pearl Harbor—which at the time looked like a US colony since Hawaii didn't become a state until 1959—because the United States was sending aid to China and they wanted us to stop.

Massive warfare tore China apart from 1911-1912 until 1945, followed by the Chinese Civil War which ended in 1949. Then came Mao's political campaigns from 1950 to 1953, the 1962 border war where China trounced India and made them a permanent enemy, and Deng Xiaoping's actions in Vietnam. Mao also launched Anti-Rightist campaigns and the Cultural Revolution to remain in power, all while the Great Famine occurred due to his Great Leap Forward, during which he kept exporting food for pocket change while people starved.

What Happens to the World if Nothing Changes?

It looks like World War III. You have to prevent these things from breaking out because once they do, look at Iran. He's going to want to show that somehow he's won.

This chart shows how many nuclear warheads each country has. When people say World War III could be next if we continue on this trajectory, my rebuttal is that we live in a nuclear-powered world where if any player gets into a serious situation, they could basically wipe out life for everybody on planet Earth through mutually assured destruction.

When he threatens NATO countries, he has been violating airspace and sending drones into the territorial waters of Bulgaria and Romania. At some point, you're into Article 5 territory. The generation who remembered World War II was really careful not to trigger that. Now, you can use a computer program to pick the megatonnage of your nuclear weapon, put it over a city of your choice, and see how many people die.

This is the problem with dark personalities like Putin running countries; he doesn't care how many people he kills. Human beings have trouble identifying dark personalities until they become Adolf Hitler and we realize there are concentration camps.

Trump's not going to back out of Iran, and it doesn't sound like Putin's going to back out of Ukraine. It is where the next Congress might impeach and convict him. I think Republicans want Democrats to do that so they can blame them and say, "No, it's your war." In fact, look for those who start wars; those are the ones you want to blame, not those who end them.

How Will History Remember Volodymyr Zelensky?

He's a hero for all time, a man who can really communicate. He told me Biden called and offered him a ride.

This is one of the most clear-cut wars of aggression you can possibly imagine, given the brutality with which the Russians are treating people. You need to get Ukraine totally on its feet and force Russia to cease dropping ordinance on everybody, giving them a massive time out from the middle powers that Carney and friends are organizing even as we speak.

Why the World May Be Turning Away From America

When the United States takes a leader like Maduro, what would you do? You counterbalance with China as the less lunatic option. The United States wants to proclaim this a US preserve, but by flexing their power, threatening people, and going into Iran and Venezuela, they have made everyone else feel less safe. We've killed our power, and now others have partnered with each other. It is a paradox of strength: the minute you use it, you lose it.

Global wars are over the nature of the world order. Will it be continentalists ruled by dictators—where if you lived in Russia and someone connected wants your business, that's it—or will we continue with democracies? Democracies are the only ones capable of generating wealth and really high per capita standards of living.

While the United States picks on immigrants, worrying about the one-off illegal who murders someone, Americans have missed who the dangerous immigrants are. I'm thinking about the tech billionaire immigrants who are now buying our elections. Many of them are foreign-born and afraid of people regulating their media platforms to slow down the lies. Elon Musk, a dysfunctional South African, has put 160 million dollars into the state of Texas. I used to live in Texas, where they say, "Don't mess with Texas," but what right does he have to buy our elections?

Recently, America seemed to have turned against Zelensky and Ukraine, but it was Donald Trump who did that; he has killed the US legacy. He is a guy who goes through serial bankruptcies and, because he is rich and has lawyers, leaves the trash behind him. A third of America voted for him, a third didn't, and the other third wouldn't get off the couch. They voted for the guy who was going to throw over the chessboard, but that turned out worse than the alternatives. If I buy a lousy pizza that I thought would look good, I reassess. If you do something consequential like voting for someone who gets into a war that tanked the economy, presumably you'll eventually say, "I used to think this, but now I think that."

Why People Unaffected by War Should Pay Attention

I'm 34 years old now. When people who understand history better than I do tell me there's a threat of World War III, part of me has grown up with such privileged order that I just can't imagine bombs flying over my head.

He hadn't seen any of this either, and he doesn't have the pleasure of averting his eyes. Our history is short and orderly. Not many have made it better, but currently the United States is making it a lot worse. We must talk across the silos that divide us, be polite to each other, and vote.

Young people today are so connected to the internet that we see war in the Middle East, Ukraine, Iran, and the horrific situation in Gaza. We see AI coming in and being told we'll have no bloody jobs. We have global warming, with warnings that everything will flood or burn, and forest fires everywhere.

The dark personality types are actually very few in number. I'm a retired professor. That's what Putin does. When you believe lies without knowing they are lies, you're spreading misinformation.

The 3 Levels of Warfare That Shape Every Conflict

At the tactical level of war, a tank has certain capabilities, range, and armor, and certain things can take it out. At the operational level, you fight a battle or a succession of battles called a campaign, putting together tank units, other units, and perhaps an information campaign.

Then there is the level that really counts: the strategic level. For politicians, this means protecting national security and promoting national prosperity. In the war in Iran, you worry about non-proliferation, yet that war is incentivizing pro-proliferation in the worst possible way and at an incredible cost. This war, the man running it, and his truly incompetent administration have enabled things that blow our alliance system—the system that will protect their children and grandchildren.

One tactic I've described before is when Trump had Zelensky in that Oval Office interview where two native English speakers, Trump and Vance, tried to humiliate him in public while he likely thought it was a routine photo op. Other tactics include denying who won the election; Joe Biden won the election. At politics' operational level, the goal is to win the election.

In the Vietnam War, they took a multiple of our casualties and won; there is no South Vietnamese government left.

Is NATO Expansion Really Threatening Russia?

People say NATO promised it wouldn't encroach on Russia's borders and then came closer and closer. But the United States didn't strong-arm anyone; people from the Soviet bloc were stampeding to NATO's doors. Germany was divided, Czechoslovakia was one thing, Austria was neutral, but Hungary, Romania, Bulgaria, and the larger Yugoslavia all wanted NATO desperately because they knew Russia wants empire.

Russia brings in cadres trained during the war—Bulgarian, Romanian, and Hungarian communist expats—to take over power ministries. They seize the military or interior ministry to determine whom you can shoot, the justice department to control arrests and courts, and the information ministry to control access to information. They also want agriculture because collectivizing and decollectivizing determines patronage possibilities.

They conduct massive purges, murdering many leaders and people who ran for other parties, and putting others in jail forever. In '53, Russians beat up Germans who weren't happy. When Hungarians said the communist system wasn't working, the Russians sent tanks and shot their head of state despite promising they wouldn't. The Russians have never atoned for or acknowledged this, so they've made up the story that NATO expansion caused these problems.

I was living in the Soviet Union in '88 and '89 during early Gorbachev, when the supply system was falling apart.

I went into one of their grocery stores; it had about 77 items total, comparable to a candy rack as you're exiting a convenience store. The smell from the rotting meat by the counters just about knocked you down. Occasionally they had items called importnaya, imported. I was eating rotting Hungarian apples because at least they could produce apples, though the Romanians made some pretty good canned tomatoes.

I believe the evidence of why these people want to be part of NATO is because of what Russia does. They look at it and say everyone else is picking on us, despite the huge things Russia has done to other people and the nerve they have to say these people are threatening them. Look at the Scandinavian countries. Why should Ukrainians become the slaves of their murderers?

Morals, norms, and honesty matter. You need accurate information from any point of view so people can come to their own conclusions. Americans have forgotten their core values found in the Declaration of Independence. It talks about the right to life—not the right to take someone else's life, but to preserve your own; liberty—not the liberty for me to tell you what to do, but to make my own choices; and the pursuit of happiness, not as you define it, but as I define it.

What Would a Trump-Putin Deal Mean for Ukraine?

In the last week or two, diesel prices at the pump rose to something like $6. Trump has made a deal with Putin for diesel exports because his war in Iran caused a global energy shock. However, the disinformation is that Russia has no capacity to export diesel in sufficient quantities to make any difference whatsoever.

Once the Iran war hits, it comes down to who produces what grades of oil and what refineries they have to refine diesel, as these refineries are set up for certain grades of output. You can change a refinery to a different grade, but it costs millions of dollars and takes time.

I was at the supermarket recently and oatmeal was $10 for a little package. Then there is the tariffing of all these food imports from Mexico and Canada, done not temporarily, but for as long as anyone alive at this moment will remember it.

Can Ukraine Actually Defeat Russia?

Ukrainians have developed various drones and are rapidly developing ballistic missiles. Musk's use of the Starlink kill switch has ensured no one serious will buy it; India decided against it, and shares for the French alternative have risen. Elon may be playing a short-term game, but it is a long-term loss.

Regarding US Patriot missile systems, if Franklin Delano Roosevelt had been president during the Biden administration when the second phase of the Ukraine war kicked off, he would have forced the company to mass produce them, explaining that profit would come from quantity rather than unit cost. Some say Zelenskyy has no chance with Trump turning his back and Putin in bed with President Xi, but Zelenskyy is developing his own missile systems.

Russia cannot afford to replace its refineries, which are based on Western tech. Ukraine, acting on its own without Starlink because the targets are over Russian territory, has blown away Yandex and other equivalents of Google. Russia has lost up to 50% of its operating oil refineries. Ukraine will become the go-to defense supplier because US equipment is too expensive, and we have a shortage of interceptors despite years of fighting. Roosevelt once told people how many tens of thousands of airplanes he wanted, and they thought he was nuts.

Russia will come for the rest of Europe, and European attitudes on security changed on a dime because of the 2022 war. Despite the disinformation Vlad the bad puts out to seem like he is winning, he is wrecking his country and is under enormous stress at 74. Eventually, the young men at the front lines—who are only children, unlike in pre-birth control Stalinist Russia—may riot, as we almost saw with Prigozhin.

The economic cost on Russia has been profound, shifting to a high-risk war footing where record defense spending consumes roughly 40% of the national budget, boosting GDP while draining health, education, and civil infrastructure. Heavy state spending, acute labor shortages from mobilization, and the emigration of hundreds of thousands of skilled professionals triggered persistent inflation, forcing the Central Bank of Russia to hike interest rates above 20%. Simultaneously, Russia lost its European energy export market, had 300 billion in Central Bank reserves frozen, and faced severe fuel shortages after drone strikes dropped refinery capacity by up to 50%.

As long as Vladimir Putin lives, he will keep doing it. The offer for the West should be however many billions they need in return for giving Vladimir Putin a retirement plan.

Who Is the Real Enemy in Today's Global Conflicts?

The continentalists in the United States see Donald Trump as the future. He wants to take over Italy and Canada. It is either a bad joke, which I don't think it is, or it is actually where Donald Trump lives, and we have a Republican Party that hasn't thrown him out of office for doing that.

I think it's apocryphal, but Churchill once said democracy is the worst system of government except for all the alternatives. It is messy and involves constant arguing, leading people like Xi Jinping to think they are superior because they have an orderly system. Except you double down on poor decisions and keep doing the same thing, and the longer you do it, the worse it gets. The young in China are not happy with the way things are.

A multi-party system is much better: accept the outcome of elections, try harder the next time, and allow people to keep developing fairer laws and rules.

Could Russia Ever Become a True Democracy?

I think the story is that Russians today are actually for the war. I've never heard of Russians who think they shouldn't own Ukraine, or that it's a bad idea to take it, even if they dislike the costs and don't want to lose children in Ukraine. So, what happens when Putin dies?

What Happens to Russia After Putin Dies?

We have deeply embedded democratic institutions for counting votes, yet even the United States is having trouble and wondering who might fiddle with the count. Russia has none of that; Putin is really good at doctoring his elections.

Think of Putin like a family tree or a mafia don with a consigliere underneath him, who in turn has their own consigliere. It is a whole network. When he dies, the question becomes which of these guys, or someone from elsewhere, will take over. Now we have many Russians with military training, which wasn't the case before. This means profound instability—a Humpty Dumpty situation. Depending on how bad the shatter is, it will take time to put Humpty Dumpty back together; I'll make up a number and say 10 years.

The democratic core should have plans on the shelf for when various dictators die, similar to a war plan. When the unexpected event happens, you have previous thinking to use as a first draft to adjust.

There is the issue of loose nukes, which was the fear during the breakup of the Soviet Union. That was one of the reasons nukes were taken away from Ukraine. Ukraine was willing because we promised to protect them, and we broke that promise. If you want to be a big boy on the block but your promises mean nothing, you lose leverage. This is where Trump is having trouble with Ukraine; since they know he sold them out and will always do so, he has no leverage over them.

The best strategies that really work are win-win. That is why the maritime order is strong and why each country in Europe has been ponying up to help Ukraine.

The Global Crises We Can't Afford to Ignore

Wars are negative sum; they destroy wealth incredibly rapidly. Since 90% of the world's trade goes by the oceans, a container ship carrying 21,000 containers is far more efficient than a train carrying 600. As flawed as international institutions are, they are the feasible way to avoid this. It is better to build institutions; if you cannot reform the UN, create a parallel institution until your government no longer does business in New York City.

China is practicing genocide. When Xi Jinping came to power in 2012, he summoned experts on the Soviet Union to ask why it collapsed, as the Communist Party of China did not want to follow that path. They told him the Soviet Union was organized on the basis of ethnicity; while Russians ran the ministries, they sponsored Uzbek dictionaries, folk dances, and embroidery. This looked great while holding together, but it meant the union shattered easily along ethnic lines. I suspect this explains Xi Jinping's genocide of the Muslims. He has put Uyghur men into concentration camps and children into schools similar to what this country did to Native American children. It is cultural genocide, raising them to be honorary Han. As for the women, it is white slavery, as China has a shortage of women of childbearing age.

Born in 1957, the year Sputnik went up with a dog on a one-way trip, I wanted to learn about Russia and China. The United States was terrified that Russians could eventually launch ballistic missiles at us. I grew up hearing Russia called the evil empire and watching the Vietnam War unfold poorly.

What makes me emotional is sorrow—watching other people and children suffer. We have adults willing to allow tremendous numbers of children to suffer. Republicans need to make it better for the generations that follow. Do the right thing; do something for them instead of grifting and supporting codenellis.

Mentioned

People

Pete Hegseth Joseph Stalin Bibi Netanyahu Helmut Kohl Volodymyr Zelenskyy Vlad the Bad Nikita Khrushchev Jessica Cook Donald Trump Ronald Reagan Deng Xiaoping Vladimir Putin Adolf Hitler Joe Biden Elon Musk orange guy Franklin Delano Roosevelt Xi Jinping

Companies

UN Security Council EU Pipedrive Bon Charge Central Bank of Russia